How to Compare Tree Trimming Quotes in Phoenix & the East Valley

 
 

To compare tree trimming quotes, check that both cover the same trees, clearance or pruning goal, amount of live canopy to be removed, and cleanup. Then compare the totals.

Say you’ve got a mesquite shading your driveway. One low branch brushes the top of your truck, but you like the shade on the west side of the house. You get two estimates. Both companies looked at the same tree. One price is lower. Which one would you take?

Put the two estimates side by side

Suppose one company quotes $850 and another quotes $1,100 for that mesquite. These prices are made up for this example.

Estimate A · $850
“Trim front mesquite. Clean up.”

Estimate B · $1,100
“Address the low branch over the driveway so the owner’s truck can clear it. Keep the canopy shading the west-facing windows. Chip and haul away cut branches. Rake the driveway and adjacent gravel.”

Would I spend the extra $250? I’d make one phone call first. I’d ask the $850 estimator, “Does your price cover the driveway clearance, keeping the shade over my windows, and hauling away the branches? Could you write that into the estimate?”

If the answer is yes, you may save $250. If the answer is no, ask for a price for the work you actually want. I’d also ask both estimators how much live canopy they expect to remove. Even the more detailed quote leaves that out.

Have two quotes in front of you?

Save the worksheet to your phone and use one page per company. A blank box shows you what to ask before signing.

Download the fillable tree trimming quote checklist (PDF)

Five things to check on your own quotes

  1. The tree and the result you want. “Could you list each tree separately and tell me what the crew is trying to accomplish on each one?”

  2. The amount of pruning. “About what percentage of the live canopy do you expect to remove, or what maximum are you allowing for? Which part of the tree does that affect?” Ask the estimator to list dead branches separately.

  3. What you want to keep. “Can you put down that I want to keep the afternoon shade over these windows?” Point out the part you care about while you’re standing together.

  4. Access and nearby property. “The side gate is narrow and the tree overhangs the pool. Does your price include the work it takes to get the branches out?”

  5. Hauling and the final price. “What leaves with the crew, what stays here, and what could change the written price?”

If one company wants to take off more, ask why

There’s a difference between getting one limb off your roof and pruning around the whole tree. Both might show up on an estimate as “tree trimming.” The second job may involve more cutting and hauling. The first can still take careful work because of what’s underneath that limb.

If the recommendations differ, ask each estimator to show you one branch they would remove and one they would leave. Then ask why. You’ll get a much better feel for their judgment, especially if keeping shade matters to you. If the companies use terms you haven’t heard before, our illustrated guide to tree trimming and pruning shows what the different approaches look like.

A message you can send either company

Thanks for coming out. Before I decide, could you update my estimate to show which tree and branches you’re addressing, roughly how much live canopy you expect to remove, and whether hauling and cleanup are included in the total? I’d also like the crew to know we want to keep the shade over ____. Could you add that to the work description?

My rule is simple. If you and the estimator stood in the yard and agreed on something important, the crew should be able to find it on the work order. That’s the quote I’d feel comfortable signing.

Next
Next

A Tree Root Is Lifting My Tucson Walkway. Can I Keep the Tree?